Daniel Beer
All Hearts Were Chilled
Leningrad: Tragedy of a City Under Siege, 1941–44
By Anna Reid
Bloomsbury 512pp £25
Anyone driving from Pulkovo Airport into St Petersburg today passes an enormous memorial to the siege of Leningrad at the edge of the city. A vast obelisk is fronted by ranks of soldiers and workers, men and women who march out fearlessly in the direction of the front line only a few kilometres to the south. Erected in the early 1970s, the monument symbolises an official Soviet and now largely unaltered Russian narrative of the selfless and united blokadniki defending their besieged city. Leningrad does not seek to overturn this powerful story of heroism completely but it does argue that the reality of the siege was a good deal more complicated and ambiguous. In a magisterial telling of the story that is by turns inspiring and appalling, Reid reconstructs the lives of those caught up in one of the key conflicts of the Second World War and one of the twentieth century’s greatest human tragedies.
The siege need not have been quite so devastating. The Soviet leadership had been caught unawares by the speed of Army Group North’s extraordinary, violent advance through the Baltic and failed to coordinate a proper evacuation of the city in the crucial window in August 1941 before the
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
The excellent new issue of Literary Review contains my review of Christopher Nolan's #Odyssey. I liked it more than Emily Wilson did (but is it possible to like it any less?)
The August issue of @Lit_Review is a cabinet of curiosities containing @djbduncan on raunchy pirates, @harrstetler on the French far Right, Emma Smith on New World imports, @wellflem on Donal Ryan, Seamus Perry on Sylvia Plath and so much more: http://literaryreview.co.uk
The world's best magazine's new issue is out now