Robert Colls
Aristocracy of Labour
An Uneasy Inheritance: My Family and Other Radicals
By Polly Toynbee
Atlantic Books 448pp £22
It’s hard to know what this book is really about. Polly Toynbee or her family? Let’s do it her way and start with the family. She belongs to a family so famous she can research it by reading biographies of her relatives. Her great-great-uncle Arnold Toynbee (1852–83) was the young Oxford don who popularised the phrase ‘Industrial Revolution’. At the same time, he cut a saintly figure in London’s East End, striving for workers’ education, and may be seen as one of the founders of the reformist settlement movement. When he died, aged thirty, from ‘overwork’, Toynbee Hall was founded in Spitalfields in his memory. His brother, Harry Toynbee (1861–1941), Polly’s great-grandfather, was general secretary of the Charity Organisation Society, a body that invented social work. Harry’s son and Polly’s grandfather, another Arnold (1889–1975), was a world-famous historian who appeared on the cover of Time magazine, though nobody quite remembers why. Polly’s great-aunt Jocelyn Toynbee was a professor of archaeology at Cambridge; another great-aunt, Margaret Toynbee, was a fellow in history at St Hugh’s, Oxford. Arnold’s first wife, Rosalind Murray, a poisonous snob according to Polly, was the daughter of Gilbert Murray (1866–1957), Regius Professor of Greek at Oxford, and Lady Mary Howard (1865–1956), daughter of the Earl of Carlisle. Somewhere up the line there was a big castle in Yorkshire.
Arnold and Rosalind had three boys. Philip, the middle one, was Polly’s father. It’s unlikely that he is remembered (in a good way) at the six prep schools that expelled him, or at Rugby School, or at Christ Church, Oxford, which admitted him. On the other hand, he might be remembered by older readers as a prominent Observer journalist. In other circles, he might be remembered for his work on behalf of the Communist Party: he was a drinking pal of Donald Maclean and a colleague of Kim Philby. To be fair, Polly doesn’t know quite what he did for them, and probably neither did he. Polly remembers him as an entertaining drunk not fit to be in charge of a pram.
Anne Powell, Polly’s mother, was the daughter of George Powell (Eton and the Grenadier Guards) and Barbara Pryor (from the Truman’s Brewery family). When Barbara was not pushing her debutante daughter round Parisian dress salons, she was a secret communist (or so she later claimed). Anne’s sister Elizabeth
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
It wasn’t until 1825 that Pepys’s diary became available for the first time. How it was eventually decrypted and published is a story of subterfuge and duplicity.
Kate Loveman tells the tale.
Kate Loveman - Publishing Pepys
Kate Loveman: Publishing Pepys
literaryreview.co.uk
Arthur Christopher Benson was a pillar of the Edwardian establishment. He was supremely well connected. As his newly published diaries reveal, he was also riotously indiscreet.
Piers Brendon compares Benson’s journals to others from the 20th century.
Piers Brendon - Land of Dopes & Tories
Piers Brendon: Land of Dopes & Tories - The Benson Diaries: Selections from the Diary of Arthur Christopher Benson by Eamon Duffy & Ronald Hyam (edd)
literaryreview.co.uk
Of the siblings Gwen and Augustus John, it is Augustus who has commanded most attention from collectors and connoisseurs.
Was he really the finer artist, asks Tanya Harrod, or is it time Gwen emerged from her brother’s shadow?
Tanya Harrod - Cut from the Same Canvas
Tanya Harrod: Cut from the Same Canvas - Artists, Siblings, Visionaries: The Lives and Loves of Gwen and Augustus John by Judith Mackrell
literaryreview.co.uk