Do Not Say We Have Nothing by Madeleine Thien - review by Marta Bausells

Marta Bausells

Bittersweet Symphony

Do Not Say We Have Nothing

By

Granta Books 480pp £12.99
 

In her Booker Prize-shortlisted Do Not Say We Have Nothing, Canadian author Madeleine Thien, the daughter of Malaysian-Chinese immigrants, offers a fresh look at the experience of exile. In Thien’s carefully crafted story, not only is her protagonist, Jiang Li-ling, suspended between two cultures, but also huge portions of history in one of those cultures, the Chinese, have been systematically erased.

In 1991, when Li-ling – or Marie, her English name – is twelve, she and her mother welcome a young girl named Ai-ming into their house in Vancouver. Ai-ming fled the bloody repression of the student protests in China two years earlier, and arrives on the back of a letter from her mother explaining that her and Marie’s fathers had been friends in China. Marie hardly knew her father: he killed himself in Hong Kong in 1989. It immediately becomes clear that Marie’s and Ai-ming’s families are linked by a fate that runs parallel to the country’s political developments. As the girls’ relationship deepens, Ai-ming unveils for her melancholy friend the intricate world of their respective ancestors.

Marie’s father, Jiang Kai, was a talented pianist and the sole survivor of a provincial family killed in the agrarian reforms of the 1950s. He became intimate friends with Ai-ming’s father, a composer named Sparrow, and his cousin, a female violinist named Zhuli, when all three were prodigies at

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter