Hilary Mantel

Black is not Jewish

The Nature of Blood

By Caryl Phillips

(Faber & Faber 213pp £15.99) order from our bookshop

There is only one rule in postwar fiction: don’t write about the Holocaust unless you are sure you can do it well. You must do it so well that it lights up the darkest days of Europe’s history, so well that you are a spark of light in that dark. Measure your work, let’s say, against the brilliant desolation of Cynthia Ozick’s The Shawl. If you can’t match it, look elsewhere for a story. You may think you can hitch a free ride on the power of brute reality, but in fact there is no theme more calculated to expose a writer’s limitations – both his literary and his psychological ones.

Royal Shakespeare Company

Sara Stewart

Follow Literary Review on Twitter