Martin Walker

Cartland Machismo

Charles de Gaulle

By

Secker & Warburg 432pp £15 order from our bookshop

Winston Churchill

By

Secker & Warburg 234pp £9.95 order from our bookshop

 

It is a sign of the times that the Great Man school of popular history is flourishing once more. The genre goes in and out of fashion according to the swing of the political pendulum. A swing to the Right, and we re-discover Great Men, the vital role of the gifted individual, the times fit for heroes. When the times are radical, the Great Men are swamped in the fashion for explaining everything in terms of vast and anonymous historical forces on whose tides the heroes are tossed like so many burnt corks.

But even in the headily radical days of the late 1960s, it would have taken all the sophistry and skill of a battalion of Marxist or leftist historians to have defined the great historical forces which Churchill and De Gaulle were supposed to represent. The fact that they were near contemporaries, and that they had so many experiences in common, would make the task no easier. Each had been a prisoner of war, Churchill of the Boers and De Gaulle of the Kaiser’s Germans. Each took care to write his own magisterial and mendaciously self-serving account of the history of his days. Each saw himself as the embodiment of the nation, as a man marked out by destiny from childhood. And each, of course, began life as an army officer, Churchill at Sandhurst and De Gaulle at St Cyr.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • 'Hart sets out to unsettle, startle and disturb. In this strange, disconcerting, radical version of a strange, disc… ,
    • Here is @MannJessica's June crime fiction round-up, discussing books by Georges Simenon, Jack Grimwood,… ,
    • John Stubbs reviews Stephen Greenblatt's latest, 'Tyrant: Shakespeare on Power' ,
    • RT : What happened when US military strategist Herman Kahn - one of Kubrick’s three models for Dr Strangelove - took LSD… ,
    • 'Pollan has no doubt that the use of psychedelics could have a powerfully beneficial effect on a range of condition… ,
    • A memoir about an Untouchable family and the 'formation of modern India': 'Ants among Elephants' by @gidla_sujatha… ,
    • RT : First founded in Edinburgh in 1979, is considered a trusted independent source for reviews of new book… ,