Christopher Silvester
Exploring the Nature of Historical Truth
Dead Certainties (Unwarranted Speculations)
By Simon Schama
Granta Books 352pp £15.99 order from our bookshop
Simon Schama is a professional historian who teaches at Harvard University. He is also a popular historian, whose 1983 book about the French Revolution, Citizens, became a well-deserved bestseller. But he is not a popular historian in the A J P Taylor mould, fascinated by problems of historical causation and able to express them in a compellingly precise style. Instead his approach is literary and digressive, seeking to establish mood and colour, given to flights of fancy (some of which appear overworked and absurd) and to 'fine' (even purple) writing. He reminds me a little of G M Young. It is the whimsicality of his inquiry and the quality of phrasing that counts.
In this book - two historical novellas bracketed together with a commentary about the nature of history - he attempts to satisfy both professional and popular audiences, and although the confection is not unpleasant I believe it falls between two stools. What is more, I think Professor Schama realises this.
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
'For all his reputation as the great theorist of democracy, Tocqueville was never an enthusiast for universal suffrage or the kind of electoral politics that went with it.'
Alan Ryan asks what Alexis de Tocqueville's ideas can teach us today.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/oui-the-people
'Within two days of arriving at the retreat, he is called away to attend the funeral of a friend killed in the Charlie Hebdo attacks ... Carrère is soon divorced and suicidal, interned in a psychiatric institution where he must slowly rebuild his life.'
https://literaryreview.co.uk/lunge-twist-pose
'Foreign-policy pundits, then as now, tended to lack subtlety, even if they could be highly articulate about a nation they did not like very much.'
Read Lucy Wooding's review of Clare Jackson's 'Devil-Land', which has won the @WolfsonHistory prize.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/the-view-from-across-the-channel