Nick Broomfield

Hang ‘Em High

Ultimate Punishment: A Lawyer's Reflections on Dealing with the Death Penalty

By

Picador 164pp £12.99 order from our bookshop

SCOTT TURROW WAS a member of the Illinois commission on the death penalty, set up by Governor George Ryan, which, although it did- not reach a unanimous decision, recommended the punishment’s abolition in April 2002. This book is a somewhat agonising account of the moral and practical dilemmas that have faced him in capital cases spanning his thirty-year legal career. At the end of it, in the very last sentence, he reveals that he voted ‘no’ when the members of the commission were asked whether Illinois should retain capital punishment; but it was clearly not a simple decision. On just the previous page he writes, ‘I admit I am still attracted to a death penalty that would be available for the crimes of unimaginable dimensions like [John Wayne] Gacy’s [the rape and murder of over thirty young men], or that would fully eliminate the moral risks that incorrigible monsters like [Henry] Brisbon [a habitual murderer] might ever satisfy their vampire appetites.’ The real reason why Turow doesn’t support the death penalty is not because he believes it is wrong for one human being to take the life of another, but because he can’t find a practical way to ensure that only the Gacys of this world get executed and no innocent gets carted off to the chopping block.

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • 'It would be nice to think that women will achieve equal pay in my lifetime, rather than to watch gloomily as stati… ,
    • In 1660, two of the signatories of King Charles I's death warrant fled across the Atlantic to New England. But were… ,
    • Howard Jacobson's sixteenth novel is 'a love story of sorts, one characterised not by physical desire or even conta… ,
    • 'The sudden immersion in the new and unfamiliar can lead people to write with a rare lack of self-consciousness' P… ,
    • 'Pools bend the rules. Clothes slip off, skin glistens, consciousness heightens. A dreamlike scenario unfolds' Jam… ,
    • 'Although he surely didn’t know W H Auden’s theory that every high C proclaims human freedom and our capacity to tr… ,
    • RT : With beginning tomorrow, we've uncovered a 1997 article from the archive reviewing 'Golf Dream… ,