Hannah Rosefield

Humane Conditions

We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves


Serpent’s Tail 336pp £7.99 order from our bookshop

Most twists come at the end. Not so in We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves, where the big reveal happens on page 77, a little under a quarter of the way through. I could review the novel without giving this reveal away. I could ramp up its universal themes and praise, vaguely, Karen Joy Fowler’s handling of family secrets, sibling rivalry and the unreliability of memory, all of which she treats with the same wry insight she brought to loneliness and friendship in The Jane Austen Book Club. But to write about We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves in this way would be to ignore what separates it from a hundred other wryly insightful novels and what explains its place as one of the two American novels on the Booker shortlist; both its singularity and the singularity of the relationship between Rosemary, Fowler’s narrator, and her sister, Fern, who disappeared when Rosemary was five years old.

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • He weeps by the side of the ocean, He weeps on the top of the hill; He purchases pancakes and lotion, And chocolate… ,
    • 'Half-way through The Conquest of Water I felt as if I had been subjected to the literary equivalent of excessive c… ,
    • 'Volume five, then, but still no end in sight. Sandbrook is clearly enjoying himself so much he can’t bear the seri… ,
    • 'By the end of the book something so weighty, stylish and impressive has been built up that one feels far nearer to… ,
    • 'Her ensuing psychotic episode is described so convincingly ... that the reader will wonder if Dobrakovová did not… ,
    • 'The perspectives complement and contest one another, amounting to a glorious, atmospheric set of ventriloquisms.'… ,
    • RT : I reviewed The Testaments for . I will not be taking any questions at this time. ,