John Lanchester
Humanists versus Theorists
Signifying Nothing: Truth's True Contents in Shakespeare's Text
By Malcolm Evans
Harvester Press 291pp £28.50 order from our bookshop
Shakespeare and the Question of Theory
By Patricia Parker & Geoffrey Hartman (edd.)
Methuen 335pp £20 order from our bookshop
In English culture, Shakespeare has become an impossibly bland and reassuring figure – a kind of continuation of the Queen Mother by other means. This makes it easy to forget how strange Shakespeare is. 'Gild the faces of the grooms withal,' says Lady Macbeth to her husband, 'for it must seem their guilt' – you can get so used to puns like that that they lose their shocking oddness. Certainly that pun shocked Dr Johnson: 'Could Shakespeare possibly mean to play on the similitude of gild and guilt?' he asked, horrified. Johnson's Shakespeare criticism remains essential because of his ability to be affronted, annoyed, upset by Shakespeare; his well-known inability to re-read King Lear is just the most famous instance of a continually heightened sensitivity. This strangeness of Shakespeare needs always to be rediscovered, by readers and by the theatre. Those productions which present King Lear as a senile brewery magnate, or perform Twelfth Night in full samurai regalia – that's what they're trying to do.
The recent tiny avalanche of theoretical work on the Bard (comprising Political Shakespeare, Alternative Shakespeares, Terry Eagleton's book, and the two volumes here under review) is an attempt to take up this work of renovation and reclamation. Shakespeare and the Question of Theory is a collection of essays by feminists,
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
'"The Last Colony" is, among other things, part of the campaign to shift the British position through political pressure. As with all good propaganda, Sands’s case is based in truth, if not the whole of it.'
https://literaryreview.co.uk/empire-strikes-back
'To her enemies she was the alien temptress who led Charles I away from the "true religion" of Protestantism and towards royal absolutism.'
Lucy Hughes-Hallett reviews @LeandadeLisle's 'colourful', 'persuasive' new biography of Henrietta Maria.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/royalist-generalissima
'Empathy is our moral portal gun, and it jams from underuse.'
Don Paterson on Portal 2, catching Covid on the Eurostar, and rereading Ian Hamilton’s 'Against Oblivion'.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/portal-agony