Tim Blanning
Listen Closely
The Politics of Opera: A History from Monteverdi to Mozart
By Mitchell Cohen
Princeton University Press 477pp £32.95
Beware of long books with short titles. The Politics of Opera looks straightforward enough, especially when the subtitle reveals that the period it covers is confined to the 17th and 18th centuries. But the amber light is triggered at once by an introduction entitled ‘Prologue: Mixtures, Boundaries, Parallels’, a mystifying triad left unexplained by what follows. What does appear is a supporting cast of non-musicians, including Machiavelli, Descartes, Hegel, Collingwood and Quentin Skinner, and an admission that the author is not a musicologist or a historian but ‘a student of political thought’. The most important of the intellectuals cited turns out to be Skinner, a historian of ideas. Connoisseurs of the school associated with him will know what to expect, although Cohen does not fully acknowledge his debt to Skinner until the very end of the book, in an appendix labelled ‘Backstage’. This should be read immediately after the introduction if the book is to make sense. He tells us there that he has ‘tried to avoid or correct my own interpretive conceits throughout the book by means of a constantly changing methodological medley’, but in reality there is just one dominant melody: the contextualisation associated with what was once called the ‘Cambridge school’.
Like all the best tunes, this is deceptively simple, lending itself to infinite improvisation, rich harmonies and arresting key changes. To recognise that a ‘great work’ does not stand in solitary splendour in a ‘great tradition’ but was also in conversation with lesser works of the same era is to
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
Knowledge of Sufism increased markedly with the publication in 1964 of The Sufis, by Idries Shah. Nowadays his writings, much like his father’s, are dismissed for their Orientalism and inaccuracy.
@fitzmorrissey investigates who the Shahs really were.
Fitzroy Morrissey - Sufism Goes West
Fitzroy Morrissey: Sufism Goes West - Empire’s Son, Empire’s Orphan: The Fantastical Lives of Ikbal and Idries Shah by Nile Green
literaryreview.co.uk
Rats have plagued cities for centuries. But in Baltimore, researchers alighted on one surprising solution to the problem of rat infestation: more rats.
@WillWiles looks at what lessons can be learned from rat ecosystems – for both rats and humans.
Will Wiles - Puss Gets the Boot
Will Wiles: Puss Gets the Boot - Rat City: Overcrowding and Urban Derangement in the Rodent Universes of John B ...
literaryreview.co.uk
Twisters features destructive tempests and blockbuster action sequences.
@JonathanRomney asks what the real danger is in Lee Isaac Chung's disaster movie.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/eyes-of-the-storm