Peter Moore
Marooned with a View
Crusoe’s Island: A Rich and Curious History of Pirates, Castaways and Madness
By Andrew Lambert
Faber & Faber 306pp £20
In his Essay on the Sea-Scurvy of 1753, Anthony Addington mapped out the horrific symptoms of the disease: ‘a low unequal Pulse … a pale-brown or livid Complexion, a Weakness and Swelling or sometimes Wasting of the Legs, a Difficulty in walking, acute transient Pains, frequent Bleedings at the Nose, stinking Breath, putrid Gums, loose Teeth, ill-condition’d Ulcers, and rotten Bones’.
In his engaging new book, the historian Andrew Lambert adds a psychological symptom to Addington’s litany of miseries. Starved of vitamin C and amino acids, he explains, the sufferer is projected into a world of heightened perception. Tastes, flavours and smells become intense. As the body crumples, the mind soars. The ‘sensory overload’ inflicted on scurvied sailors, he writes, was not unlike the sensations the young Humphry Davy memorably experienced while high on laughing gas: ‘blinded by dazzling visions, startled by enhanced hearing, and isolated from reality in a parallel world of his own imagination’.
This insight of modern science illuminates the past in new ways. In particular, Lambert writes, it accounts for some of the heady travellers’ tales that sailors carried back to Britain with them. Of these 18th-century fabrications, few were as spellbinding as the descriptions of Juan Fernández, a cluster of islands in the South Pacific. Situated four hundred miles off the coast of Chile, lost in the immensity of the ocean, these islands, according to returning travellers, were an ‘English heaven’, a land of murmuring brooks, enchanted valleys and melodic birds.
The three islands that comprise the Juan Fernández archipelago were first seen by Spanish explorers in the 1570s and christened with workmanlike names: Más a Tierra, Más Afuera and Santa Clara. Their significance was their location. Had they stood a little closer to Valparaíso, they would have been absorbed into the Spanish empire. Had they lain further out into the Pacific, they might well have remained undiscovered until Cook’s voyages. But as it was, they existed in a liminal space, on the edge of the known world. When the English learned of their existence in the 1680s, the court was gripped by anticipation. One of Charles II’s advisers speculated that were they to be populated they ‘would prove the sharpest thorn that ever touched the Spaniards’.
It is here, amid the venturing schemes of the 17th century, that Lambert’s Crusoe’s Island opens. First to the prize, of course, were the buccaneers – men such as John Eaton and William Dampier, who used the islands as launch pads for raids on Spanish silver ships. This is vibrant history and Lambert teases out the individual stories of treachery and opportunism among the privateers. He tells, most significantly, the stories of two marooned sailors, a ‘Miskito’ Indian named Will and a bluff Scotsman called Alexander Selkirk, who found themselves abandoned on Más a Tierra, left for several years to eke out an existence among the island’s goats.
Selkirk is famously thought to have provided Daniel Defoe with a model for Robinson Crusoe, with Will the inspiration for Man Friday. Defoe, a master of manipulating truthful accounts – Joseph Addison neatly described him as ‘a false, shuffling, prevaricating rascal’ – did his utmost to portray Robinson Crusoe as a factual, autobiographical narrative. It was a hoax that many believed and it had the effect of foisting a curious identity on Juan Fernández. It became a half-real, half-imagined place. Everyone carried a vision of Crusoe’s island around in their heads. Perhaps with Desert Island Discs, we still do.
Lambert shows that those who visited ‘the magical island of Daniel Defoe’ in the decades after Robinson Crusoe’s publication saw it through his eyes. Life began to imitate art. The perceived prosperity of the territory helped swell the South Sea Bubble in the 1720s. It lured naval officers such as Commodore George Anson, who wrote vividly of sailing to the ‘long-wished for island of Juan Fernández … this enchanting landskip, which still improved upon us the further we advanced’. Published accounts such as Anson’s ‘made Juan Fernández romantic’, Lambert writes, ‘the better to imagine heroic Robinsonian narratives’.
Emerging at an important moment in the development of Britain, myths about Crusoe and Juan Fernández lodged deep. William Cowper wrote verses about the islands and politicians imagined them as new Gibraltars, keys to the Pacific Ocean. It was a potent brew and Lambert traces the development of the seesaw relationship between Britain and these islands, which, oddly enough, the British never formally owned. In the 19th century, romance gave way to practicality. The islands became a favoured shelter for whalers and sealers. Herman Melville visited, as did Richard Henry Dana and several Victorian naval officers, among them Frederick Walpole, who left a tender travelogue of his stay. In the 20th century the islands were settled and exploited, and later surveyed and conserved. Renamed Robinson Crusoe Island and Alejandro Selkirk Island by the Chilean government, Más a Tierra and Más Afuera were repackaged once again in the 1960s, this time as a lure for tourists.
Lambert charts all of this with a historian’s steady eye. His story spans five centuries and is told chronologically in nimble chapters. With so much to say, the action whips along at a pace, meaning that artful storytelling is often exchanged for frank analysis. Selkirk’s four and a bit years on Más a Tierra, for instance, fill barely three pages from marooning to rescue.
But as Lambert makes plain in his preface, he is questing after something deeper: that elusive quality, ‘Britishness’. The islands ‘acquired an abiding place in the national culture because every generation found a reason to return’. Lambert revisits this theme in a trenchant chapter towards the end of the book. During the last forty years of the 20th century, he argues, our imperial past – one rooted in distant islands like Juan Fernández – was replaced by a newly minted European one, created to suit political agendas. ‘The process will only be complete when Trafalgar Square is bulldozed, the Victory recycled, and the mortal remains of Lord Nelson cast out of St Paul’s,’ he writes.
Melodramatic, perhaps. But it has been a disorientating few months in domestic politics since Crusoe’s Island went to print. And as the EU totters and our union falters, Lambert’s enquiry begins to feel less like a blithe foray into the past and more like an urgent investigation into that strange blend of qualities that bound Britain together in the first place.
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
Literary Review
@Lit_Review ·Saki ought to be a biographer’s dream, with his aunt-haunted childhood, a stint in the Burmese police, reporting from tsarist Russia and death on the Western Front at forty-five.
What, then, makes him so elusive? @djtaylorwriter investigates.
D J Taylor - Laughter in the Margins
D J Taylor: Laughter in the Margins - Super-Beast: The Mysterious Life of Saki by Oliver Soden
literaryreview.co.uk
Literary Review
@Lit_Review ·Congratulations to M John Harrison on winning this year’s #BookerPrize
You can read our review, paywall-free, at the link below:
Olivia Ho - Close Encounters
Olivia Ho: Close Encounters - The End of Everything by M John Harrison
literaryreview.co.uk
Literary Review
@Lit_Review ·For decades, Lee Krasner was cast as the victim of a patriarchy, while Jackson Pollock was flattened into a painterly cowboy in an American art that denied its European debts.
@darwent_charles considers what changes when the two are seen as a pair.
Charles Darwent - Dripping with Talent
Charles Darwent: Dripping with Talent - Krasner and Pollock: Past Continuous by David Breslin & Brinda Kumar
literaryreview.co.uk