Christopher Caldwell
Model Thinkers
The Assumptions Economists Make
By Jonathan Schlefer
Harvard University Press/Belknap Press 356pp £21.95 order from our bookshop
Economists have earned our distrust. They oversimplify things, presenting normal elements of an economy – such as strikes, tariffs and corruption – as aberrations. They overcomplicate things, too, smuggling ideological agendas into objective-looking newspaper columns. And they do it all in the name of ‘science’, even as their spectacularly unscientific recent failures have done nothing to moderate their arrogance. Well into his career as an editor at MIT’s Technology Review, Jonathan Schlefer armed himself with a doctorate in political science so that he might talk back to economic theorists in their own idiom. One of the results is The Assumptions Economists Make, a knowledgeable but uneven broadside against neoclassical economics.
By neoclassical economics, Schlefer means the kind taught in American university textbooks, such as the late MIT professor Paul Samuelson’s perennial undergraduate bestseller and the standard graduate text by Berkeley macroeconomist David Romer. But he also intends to draw a contrast with two ‘classical’ economists: Adam Smith (whom he belittles)
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Where now for active asset-management in the wake of the Woodford Equity Income collapse? My review of @davidricketts's When the Fund Stops and @OwenWalker0's Built On A Lie in @Lit_Review https://literaryreview.co.uk/stock-horror-2
'What if the 1492 "discovery" of America had been a fiasco, the major effect of which was to alert the Incas to the existence of a land to the east that might be ripe for conquest?'
@lieutenantkije on Laurent Binet's new novel, 'Civilisations'.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/1492-and-all-that
'Humans may be the supremely musical animal, but, with or without us, this is a musical planet.'
@MathewJLyons on how music on earth began.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/symphony-of-a-thousand-millennia