Charles Saumarez-Smith

National Trust

Who Owns Antiquity? Museums and the Battle over Our Ancient Heritage

By

Princeton University Press 228pp £14.95 order from our bookshop

I was recently asked to give a paper at a conference on the subject of ‘Collecting Practices in Lebanon’ held at the American University of Beirut. I spoke on some of the problems of adding to the collections of the National Gallery and the worrying prospect that museums and galleries in the United Kingdom would no longer be able to add to their collections in the same way that they have in the past, due to the absence of dedicated state support and the increasing cost of the greatest works of Western European art. During the questions, someone at the back of the room stood up and asked how it felt to live in a country where so much of the wealth of the Middle East had accumulated. I misunderstood the question and thought that he was asking me about my attitude towards restitution. My answer was greeted with a slight undercurrent of sarcastic laughter, since it was obvious to them that I had not given deep thought to the fundamental issue of imbalance between collections in the Middle East, the heartland of ancient cultures and civilisations, and collections in Western Europe, which have been enriched by at least two centuries of trade, wealth, archaeology and loot. The message was: you already have more than enough; you are not entitled to complain.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • What a charming, candid blogpost from one of our dear contributing editors. ,
    • RT : The first guess from one of my 1st graders was “death” and such an awed, somber, reflective hush fell over the clas… ,
    • Merry Christmas from Literary Review! Hope your stockings were laden with books, and the tree bending under the weight of further books....,
    • Last minute Christmas gift required? We're offering discounts on all our subscriptions (20% no less!) with the cod… ,
    • In this issue's 'Silenced Voices', Lucy Popescu writes of Thailand's restrictive lese-majesty laws and their latest… ,
    • "Gunn was a disciple of the American formalist Yvor Winters, but Winters’s poetry could never give off such a scent… ,
    • Christmas gift hunting? Why not give the gift of being even better read? We're offering discounts on all our subscr… ,