David Gilmour

One Nation or Two?

Violencia: A New History of Spain – Past, Present and the Future of the West

By

Constable 418pp £25 order from our bookshop

After the Fall: Crisis, Recovery and the Making of a New Spain

By

Weidenfeld & Nicolson 307pp £20 order from our bookshop

In lines written in 1912, the Sevillian poet Antonio Machado asked God to protect a young Spanish child because otherwise ‘one of the two Spains’ would ‘freeze his heart’. The concept of las dos Españas, two Spains in perpetual conflict has a long history, and it is given vigorous celebration in Jason Webster’s Violencia, in which Machado’s words are quoted. Webster sees the two Spains reflected in the person of Santiago (St James), the son of Zebedee and a disciple of Jesus. Although his connection with Spain is entirely mythical – according to legend, his remains were found in Galicia in the ninth century – he became the country’s patron saint and is seen as the personification of its dual nature: St James the apostle of Christ, and Santiago Matamoros the knight charging on a white horse to slay the ‘Moors’ and reconquer Spain for Christianity. (Webster also grants him a third identity, that of pilgrim and seeker, a man of peace.)

The author sees the two sides of the Spanish soul locked in incessant struggle, one always trying to dominate and annihilate the other: it is ‘a refrain running through the history of the Peninsula’. This has given rise to ‘patterns’ in Spanish history, ‘dualistic conflicts’ between light and dark, between enlightened people and authoritarian conservatives. ‘True to a repeated pattern throughout its history’, Spain is united for a time and then falls apart; all its collapses are caused by civil wars. ‘Ages-long Manichaean struggles’ do not, however, provide the only pattern. We also have the ‘Cassandra pattern, which stretches back over many centuries’, condemning Spain or Spaniards to make prophecies that no one will heed. And we have a still more recondite
pattern, that of a ‘Man from the East’ arriving in Spain and ‘bringing new ways and civilization’. These men include St James, who came from Judaea, the Emir Abd al-Rahman, who came from Damascus, and King Charles III, who came from Naples and ruled Spain in the 18th century. Not many people, I suspect, would compare that Bourbon monarch with Webster’s other ‘Men from the East’.

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • He weeps by the side of the ocean, He weeps on the top of the hill; He purchases pancakes and lotion, And chocolate… ,
    • 'Half-way through The Conquest of Water I felt as if I had been subjected to the literary equivalent of excessive c… ,
    • 'Volume five, then, but still no end in sight. Sandbrook is clearly enjoying himself so much he can’t bear the seri… ,
    • 'By the end of the book something so weighty, stylish and impressive has been built up that one feels far nearer to… ,
    • 'Her ensuing psychotic episode is described so convincingly ... that the reader will wonder if Dobrakovová did not… ,
    • 'The perspectives complement and contest one another, amounting to a glorious, atmospheric set of ventriloquisms.'… ,
    • RT : I reviewed The Testaments for . I will not be taking any questions at this time. ,