Ireland’s Misfortune: The Turbulent Life of Kitty O’Shea by Elisabeth Kehoe - review by Mary Kenny

Mary Kenny

Parnell’s Passion

Ireland’s Misfortune: The Turbulent Life of Kitty O’Shea

By

Atlantic Books 586pp £19.99
 

First, Charles Stewart Parnell’s mistress was never actually called ‘Kitty O’Shea’, as Elisabeth Kehoe quite properly explains in this meticulous biography. ‘Kitty’ was a public, and perhaps pejorative, nickname that has principally lived on as a name for Irish-themed pubs: the Kitty O’Shea Tavern and Inn. It is supposed to signal an ooh-la-la sauciness and Madame Naughty in a basque – Parnell’s fancy-woman who was allegedly the cause of ‘Ireland’s Misfortune’.

But of course it wasn’t like that at all: it never is. It was an infinitely more complicated and multi-layered story of passionate commitment, involving poor judgement, character blindspots, and, above all, a chronic problem with money. Far from being a saucy sexpot, Mrs Katharine O’Shea was a strong-minded, cultivated and self-assured Victorian matron with whom the otherwise frighteningly icy Parnell was utterly smitten. 

The legend, by now, is famous – made so by W B Yeats’s ballad (‘A husband that had sold his wife / And after that betrayed’) and James Joyce’s matchless Parnell episode in Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. The aloof but bewitching Charles Stewart Parnell, known as

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter