Henry IV by Chris Given-Wilson - review by Jonathan Sumption

Jonathan Sumption

Reign of the Usurper

Henry IV

By

Yale University Press 590pp £30 order from our bookshop
 

Henry IV has had a bad press. He usurped the throne of England in 1399 and is generally thought to have murdered his predecessor, a poor start in an age of strong legitimist sentiment. The Church would remember him as the first king since Henry II to have had an archbishop executed. To the Victorian advocates of English constitutional exceptionalism Henry was the king whose weakness and incapacity happily inaugurated a golden age of parliamentary government. To the Welsh and Scottish, he was the determined enemy of their nations. In the Protestant tradition, Henry was the king who, a century before Luther, snuffed out the abortive reformation of the Lollards. To liberals of our own day, he was the enemy of freedom of conscience, the man who introduced to England the practice of burning heretics at the stake. To generations of history students, Henry IV’s reign has been a mere interval between the dramatic upheavals of Richard II’s reign and the glorious wars of Henry V, a dreary succession of violent and incomprehensible rebellions. Only a decade ago a panel of historians assembled by the BBC voted Henry’s Lord Chancellor Thomas Arundel as one of the most wicked Englishmen in history. But the abiding image of the king is, as always, Shakespeare’s. In the playwright’s eyes he remained throughout his reign the man of 1399, racked by guilt and self-hatred. ‘God knows … By what by-paths and indirect crook’d ways/I met this crown,’ says the dying king in Henry IV Part II, ‘and I myself know well/How troublesome it sat upon my head.’

This scholarly and readable contribution to Yale’s English Monarchs series fills an important gap. For more than a century, the standard account of Henry IV’s reign, so far as there was one, was the four-volume tombstone published by J H Wylie between 1884 and 1898. Wylie was an inspector of

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter