Sarah A Smith
Sarah A Smith Looks at three collections of short stories
Seven Tales of Sex and Death
By Patricia Duncker
Picador 228pp £16.99 order from our bookshop
The Whole Story and Other Stories
By Ali Smith
Hamish Hamilton 192pp £10.99 order from our bookshop
Things You Should Know
By A M Homes
(Granta Books 213pp A8.99) order from our bookshop
The short story is a demanding genre – any example needs to be flawless to deliver satisfaction in so few pages. And producing a collection is equally tough – put too many slight tales together and the whole volume seem tarnished. It is not a form to be taken lightly.
Patricia Duncker's fiercely intelligent, witty fiction suggests that she is not a woman to take anything lightly. Seven Tales of Sex and Death opens with a rather alarming note explaining her purpose. 'These tales are night-pieces ... written to disturb and provoke', she reveals. 'I refused to toe the line of political correctness, middle-class morality and good taste.' Not wasting any time, she starts the offensive with 'Stalker', a rape fantasy, which owes somethng to the Jill Dando case and something to classical mythology. This is followed up by 'Sophia Walters Shaw', an equally unpleasant, dystopian tale in which women are literally divided into wives and whores. At least we were warned.
The trouble with setting out to shock, however, is that it very rarely works. Duncker's apocalyptic stories had me checking my doors were locked at night, much as the late-night horror films she acknowledges in her introduction might. But the Grand Guignol to which she aspires isn't exactly subversive. It
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
'Perhaps, rather than having diagnosed a real societal malaise, she has merely projected onto an entire generation a neurosis that actually affects only a small number of people.'
@HoumanBarekat on Patricia Lockwood's 'No One is Talking About This'.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/culturecrisis
*Offer ends in TWO days*
Take advantage of our February offer: a six-month subscription for only £19.99.
https://www.mymagazinesub.co.uk/literary-review/promo/literaryfebruary/
'Nourished on a diet of exceptionalism and meritocracy, millennials internalised the harmful falsehood that hard work necessarily yields success. The very least they should settle for is a "cool job", one that ... is the focus of their "passion".'
https://literaryreview.co.uk/workers-twerkers