Patrick O’Connor

Singing & Silence

On Opera

By

Yale University Press 149pp £19.99 order from our bookshop

Bernard Williams was once introduced to Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau as ‘a great lover of opera’. The famous baritone gave one of his characteristic little smiles, and replied ‘Ah, I am not’. As a philosopher Williams could take this in his stride, and an essay he might have written would have concerned the interpretive artist’s frustration with the material with which he has to work.

It was a visit to the opera, to a performance of Janacek’s The Makropoulos Case, that inspired one of Williams’s most influential essays, ‘Reflections on the Tedium of Immortality’ (in Problems of the Self, 1973). In Janacek’s opera, the central figure is a woman who has drunk the elixir of life, and has already lived for 300 years. ‘Her unending life has come to a state of boredom, indifference and coldness.’ She has reached the joyless conclusion that ‘in the end it is all the same, singing and silence’.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • Here is @MannJessica's June crime fiction round-up, discussing books by Georges Simenon, Jack Grimwood,… ,
    • John Stubbs reviews Stephen Greenblatt's latest, 'Tyrant: Shakespeare on Power' ,
    • RT : What happened when US military strategist Herman Kahn - one of Kubrick’s three models for Dr Strangelove - took LSD… ,
    • 'Pollan has no doubt that the use of psychedelics could have a powerfully beneficial effect on a range of condition… ,
    • A memoir about an Untouchable family and the 'formation of modern India': 'Ants among Elephants' by @gidla_sujatha… ,
    • RT : First founded in Edinburgh in 1979, is considered a trusted independent source for reviews of new book… ,
    • 'In different ways Hatherley makes gritty Lódź and poor old which-country-are-we-in-this-week Lviv sound entrancing… ,