Simon Blackburn
Taking a Bearing
How the World Thinks: A Global History of Philosophy
By Julian Baggini
Granta Books 398pp £20
Insularity is a professional vice among academic philosophers. It is not so much that the British read British philosophers (and some ancient Greeks), the Germans read German philosophers (and some ancient Greeks), and so on across the world. It is rather that we become trapped in little bubbles of problems and approaches, and find it difficult to recognise alternatives as the real thing: philosophy as well as something else, such as literature or religion. The habitat we have settled into provides enough interest and nourishment, and it is rather daunting to imagine any other. Some of us, feeling a little guilty about this, suppose that one day, when we are less busy, we might travel, just as someone newly retired supposes that he or she might eventually take a cruise, perhaps to India, China or Japan. But often enough, we do not manage to turn the wish into the deed. And if we do, we often find ourselves to be mere tourists, gaping at the surfaces of things, unable to comprehend the life underneath them.
Julian Baggini, a prolific and engaging philosophical writer, is made of sterner stuff, and this fascinating book is the result. He has not only undertaken to acquaint himself with different traditions of thought, but has also travelled to different countries and institutions, attended multicultural conferences and workshops, and interviewed representatives of different traditions. He has done so in the spirit of a genuine traveller rather than a tourist, and the results are always intriguing and often illuminating.
He is, of course, aware that the undertaking is fraught with problems. At the beginning of such a quest, we can only hear the words of other traditions through translation into our own. The question of what is real understanding and what is an imposition of the concepts and
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
Margaret Atwood has become a cultural weathervane, blamed for predicting dystopia and celebrated for resisting it. Yet her ‘memoir of sorts’ reveals a more complicated, playful figure.
@sophieolive introduces us to a young Peggy.
Sophie Oliver - Ms Fixit’s Characteristics
Sophie Oliver: Ms Fixit’s Characteristics - Book of Lives: A Memoir of Sorts by Margaret Atwood
literaryreview.co.uk
For a writer so ubiquitous, George Orwell remains curiously elusive. His voice is lost, his image scarce; all that survives is the prose, and the interpretations built upon it.
@Dorianlynskey wonders what is to be done.
Dorian Lynskey - Doublethink & Doubt
Dorian Lynskey: Doublethink & Doubt - Orwell: 2+2=5 by Raoul Peck (dir); George Orwell: Life and Legacy by Robert Colls
literaryreview.co.uk
The court of Henry VIII is easy to envision thanks to Hans Holbein the Younger’s portraits: the bearded king, Anne of Cleves in red and gold, Thomas Cromwell demure in black.
Peter Marshall paints a picture of the artist himself.
Peter Marshall - Varnish & Virtue
Peter Marshall: Varnish & Virtue - Holbein: Renaissance Master by Elizabeth Goldring
literaryreview.co.uk