Richard Overy
Cases of Shell Shock
A War of Nerves: Soldiers and Psychiatrists 1914-1994
By Ben Shephard
Jonathan Cape 480pp £20
What does it take to fight in a modern war? Why did some men crack on the Western Front in the First World War and others endure? If 30 per cent of American troops fighting the Italians and Germans in North Africa became psychiatric casualties, what made the other 70 per cent (if they survived) different? Many of those who stayed and fought might have given the simple answer, 'courage'; but this begs in turn a question to which there is still no consensual answer: What is courage?
These issues are the very heart of Ben Shephard’s utterly absorbing study of the century-long relationship between psychiatry and the military. It has been an unhappy marriage; the two sides had a brief honeymoon, rowed, made up and rowed again. The real source of the discord is made clear in this remarkably rich and dramatic narrative: the army wanted men to be 'cured' quickly and returned to battle; the psychiatrists, all save the few sadists who agreed with the army, wanted to study neuroses in the raw and to find adequate therapeutic responses.
The starting point was shell shock. Shephard is at his best describing the bemused reaction of the authorities to tens of thousands of apparently fit young men manifesting debilitating gaits, tremors and tics, which rendered them quite incapable of further military service. Since the idea of a psychiatric
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
Don't ask about the dress code, don't talk about your spouse too much, flirt with everyone
Andrew Martin on the rules, pleasures and pitfalls of living in Paris
Andrew Martin - Bobos versus Beaufs
Andrew Martin: Bobos versus Beaufs - Impossible City: Paris in the Twenty-First Century by Simon Kuper
literaryreview.co.uk
for the latest edition of @Lit_Review I worked on some excellent pieces – @MortenHoiJensen on Kafka
@ellafox_m on @mimpathy (Honor Levy)
@profrhodrilewis on Shakespeare novels
@edcumming on Kaliane Bradley
@zoeguttenplan on @NationalTheatre's Dickens show
wrote about MY FIRST BOOK (@GrantaBooks) for @Lit_Review, a book that I think makes difficult things look very easy: