Went the Day Well? Witnessing Waterloo by David Crane; Waterloo: Great Battle Series by Alan Forrest - review by Saul David

Saul David

Our Finest Hour?

Went the Day Well? Witnessing Waterloo

By

William Collins 366p £20

Waterloo: Great Battle Series

By

Oxford University Press 240pp £18.99
 

Now that the initial deluge of books commemorating the bicentenary of the Battle of Waterloo has slowed to a trickle, it is refreshing to see the publication of two histories that observe 18 June 1815 from a much broader cultural perspective.

David Crane has form with this type of approach. His Empires of the Dead, an account of the creation of the War Graves Commission, was described by one reviewer as the ‘most original, shortest and best written of the year’s tsunami of books on the impact of the Great War’ and was deservedly shortlisted for the Samuel Johnson Prize. He tries to do something similar with Went the Day Well?, shifting the narrative from the battlefield to Britain and back again and working in a huge cast of disparate characters in contrasting settings. His declared intention is to explore ‘the intersection of the private and public spheres’ and the ‘ways in which individuals are touched by remote events, and how much – or how little – of what we usually think of as mainstream history actually impinged on the lives of ordinary men and women who witnessed Waterloo’.

The book is broken up into twenty-four main chapters, each one representing an hour of the day of battle. Of course, to give proper context the story is not confined to that hour alone, nor is the time always particularly relevant. The first chapter – ‘Midnight: Belgium’ – introduces Magdalene