Brilliant Effects: A Cultural History of Gem Stones & Jewellery by Marcia Pointon - review by Jonathan Beckman

Jonathan Beckman

All That Glitters

Brilliant Effects: A Cultural History of Gem Stones & Jewellery


Yale University Press 426pp £45 order from our bookshop

Jewels have always been morally ambiguous. The Gospel of Matthew might have compared the kingdom of heaven to a ‘pearl of great price’, but jewels continue to signify vanity, indulgence and sexual availability. The bijoux indiscrets of Diderot’s novel were gossiping pudenda, and pearls have always been associated with female anatomy. Jewellery is designed for consumption by others. It draws attention and, at its most effective, enhances the wearer. Jean-André Rouquet, an eighteenth-century French miniaturist, sounds strikingly contemporary when writing of the power of gems: ‘The brilliancy and value of jewels is one of the surest means of adding something to the importance of our being; they proclaim us from afar; they extend, as it were, the limits of our existence.’ Yet the more magnificent the jewellery, the more threatening it can be. The wearer’s ugliness might contrast unfavourably with the sparkle of the stones (as with Cinderella’s sisters), or her personality be lost in the dazzle. 

Brilliant Effects is not as wide-ranging as its subtitle suggests. It almost exclusively deals with the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, and it is paintings that invariably provide evidence about the semiotics of jewellery. (Literature, in which images of gems have often been deployed to reflect on a work’s

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Princeton - Shame

Follow Literary Review on Twitter