Frank McLynn
An Archer Could Beat the Knight in Armour
Medieval Warfare: A History
By Maurice Keen (ed)
Oxford University Press 340pp £25
This is a series of thirteen essays designed to bring before the general reader the fruits of the latest research on medieval warfare. After half a dozen chapters, laid out chronologically from the Carolingians in France to the end of the Hundred Years War (with a brief coda on the years 1453–1526), the book switches to themes, including arms and armour, castles, mercenaries, non-combatants, naval battles and the coming of new technologies such as guns and gunpowder. The emphasis is overwhelmingly on Western Europe, and in this respect the book’s title is a misnomer. More significant military successes in the Middle Ages were gained by the Mongols, the Turks (both Seljuk and Ottoman) and the Byzantines, all of whom feature in this book largely as ‘noises off’.
The most potent image of medieval warfare is the knight in armour. The Byzantine princess Anna Comnena, who observed Norman knights during the First Crusade, wrote in the Alexiad that the mounted ‘Frank’ was irresistible ‘so long as the opposition everywhere gives ground’. As John Gillingham remarks in his essay, historians have usually missed this crucial proviso. Cavalries were devastating when pursuing and ‘mopping up’ a defeated enemy after a battle, but their usefulness during the battle has been wildly exaggerated. In fact, faced with a resolute infantry, knights invariably retreated in disarray. This has been obscured by the medieval chroniclers. Aristocrats themselves, they recorded the deeds of their mounted peers and played down the achievements of the foot soldiers, who came from a lower social class.
As the contributors to this volume make clear, it was the archers who usually decided the outcome of medieval battles. This was the case at Courtrai (1304), Sluys (1340), Crécy (1346), Poitiers (1356) and Agincourt (1415). The cavalry could be decisive if a charge was launched at exactly the right
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
When @djbduncan notices the text for a literary jigsaw puzzle had been written by a former colleague, his head spins. A wild surmise. Are jigsaws REF-able?
Dennis Duncan - The W Factor
Dennis Duncan: The W Factor
literaryreview.co.uk
In an effort to scold drinkers, Victorian temperance societies furiously marked every drinking establishment with a red X on city maps. It was a spectacular case of propaganda backfiring.
@foxtosser explores the history of drink maps
Edward Brooke-Hitching - From Beer Street to Gin Lane
Edward Brooke-Hitching: From Beer Street to Gin Lane - Drink Maps in Victorian Britain by Kris Butler
literaryreview.co.uk
How did a workers’ insurance agent who died of tuberculosis at the age of forty become a global literary icon?
@MortenHoiJensen on Kafka's metamorphosis
Morten Høi Jensen - Paranoid Humanoid
Morten Høi Jensen: Paranoid Humanoid - Metamorphoses: In Search of Franz Kafka by Karolina Watroba; Kafka: Making o...
literaryreview.co.uk