Rosemary Stoyle

Anorexic Emily

Emily Brontë: A Chainless Soul

By Katherine Frank

Hamish Hamilton 293pp £14.99 order from our bookshop


Chainless souls are a bit like stray dogs; you feel sympathy for them in theory but you don’t really want to be landed with them for very long. Katherine Frank’s A Chainless Soul, the first biography of Emily Brontë for twenty years, does underline very clearly how regularly Emily and her brother and sisters were returned to sender when they made their rare sorties from home. Poetry may be delicate and sensitive, endearing and appealing, the poet quite other. Meeting one’s favourite in the flesh isn’t always a riotous success. Not that this is Frank’s theme. Like most biographers she has grown close to her subject – in fact these two portraits of nineteenth-century novelist and twentieth-century biographer, on front and back cover, display a striking likeness between the two; something about the set of the head and the intensity of the gaze links them. Frank’s particular theme and ‘discovery’ – unattractively and unaccountably advertised on the inside cover as ‘feminist perspective’ – is the suggestion that Emily was anorexic. The immediate anxiety that this is going to be an unbalanced and overstated interpretation is unfounded. The preface shows her standpoint to be carefully argued, confident and somehow convincing. In fact it is remarkably down-to-earth, as it considers the possibility that Emily’s often-quoted mysticism may have been the distorted consciousness induced by fasting. Frank has also wisely decided that Charlotte Brontë is not an unbiased witness and she tries to interpret Emily from a variety of sources: her poetry, her novels, her fantasy writings, the comments of others.

Subscribe to read the full article



Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • RT : I've got approx. 100 copies of from early 1990s-2000s to give away (most w/ covers).… ,
    • 'I Contain Multitudes is popular science writing at its best.' Wendy Moore is fascinated by a study on microbes ,
    • 'Costume of the life force? Words fail.' Germaine Greer on an ode to the condom ,
    • It's Write on Kew for the next four days. There are free copies of Literary Review about; why not dip your toe into the magazine?,
    • Which sci-fi author time-travelled to ancient Rome and lived a parallel life a persecuted Christian named Thomas? ,
    • You can pick up free copies of Literary Review at Write On Kew, which begins tomorrow. Fill your boots (with magazines).,
    • Michael Burleigh reads a survey of the rise of Asia ,