Crass Market by D J Taylor

D J Taylor

Crass Market

 

Highbrow-baiting is such a time-honoured national pastime that you might think newspaper editors would get tired of it once in a while. But no: Janet Street-Porter was reliably on hand in The Independent on the morning after this autumn’s Man Booker Prize winner was announced with a feisty little harangue entitled ‘Booker Prize snobs have lost the plot’. According to Street-Porter, the British publishing industry is ‘the last bastion of true snobbishness’. Literary festivals, which she attends with extreme reluctance, are the resort of ‘middle-class luvvies’ come to ‘pat each other on the back’. Worse even than this, to her democratising mind, is the ‘massive disparity … between books people actually buy and read … and the stuff that gets reviewed favourably in newspapers’. Although the items chosen by Richard and Judy will sell more copies than any Man Booker winner, Street-Porter grandly concludes, ‘booksellers still regard the words mass market as really meaning of second-rate value’.

The most creaking flaw in this thesis might be its definition of ‘snobbishness’, which you and I would probably mark down as Thackeray’s ‘assumption of a false superiority’ but which the Independent on Sunday’s editor-at-large seems to regard as the filing of any judgement whatsoever. But however crudely expressed, or

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

RLF - March

A Mirror - Westend

Follow Literary Review on Twitter