Tim Stanley
Lives of Others
History’s People: Personalities and the Past
By Margaret MacMillan
Profile 269pp £14.99 order from our bookshop
I’m sure there’s some point to this book but I can’t find it. Margaret MacMillan has produced a collage of history-making personalities that doesn’t make an argument for itself. Its potted bios are categorised by qualities of character such as ‘hubris’, ‘curiosity’ or ‘daring’. The labels are arbitrary: all three apply to Winston Churchill but he only appears under the heading ‘daring’. The message is unclear. Are we supposed to beware leaders with too much daring or aspire to it ourselves? At times, MacMillan comes dangerously close to business book prose: ‘How to succeed on the stock market – the Joseph Stalin way!’ One can easily imagine finding this book in an airport lounge, endorsed by Donald Trump.
The style is excellent and the sweep of the text is ambitious. MacMillan is a venerable historian who produced a superb and precisely researched account of Nixon’s trip to China. This makes the book’s vagueness all the more puzzling. At times it feels like a retread of things MacMillan is
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
'Perhaps, rather than having diagnosed a real societal malaise, she has merely projected onto an entire generation a neurosis that actually affects only a small number of people.'
@HoumanBarekat on Patricia Lockwood's 'No One is Talking About This'.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/culturecrisis
*Offer ends in TWO days*
Take advantage of our February offer: a six-month subscription for only £19.99.
https://www.mymagazinesub.co.uk/literary-review/promo/literaryfebruary/
'Nourished on a diet of exceptionalism and meritocracy, millennials internalised the harmful falsehood that hard work necessarily yields success. The very least they should settle for is a "cool job", one that ... is the focus of their "passion".'
https://literaryreview.co.uk/workers-twerkers