Pressed hard by the press, television and books, we struggle these days to understand why American and British soldiers torture and – it is alleged – kill prisoners. Having finally been arrested, charged and faced with sentences for their acts at Abu Ghraib and Camp Bread Basket, the convicted men and women say they were following orders. That was also the plea of German soldiers who did terrible things on a far vaster scale during the Second World War. It turns out to have been misleading: in W John Koch’s sometimes over-detailed memoir – as in some other Holocaust studies – we learn that German soldiers could refuse to murder Jews. But, in the blood-curdling scene that makes No Escape unforgettable, when Koch refused, another soldier was on hand to shoot the prisoners, and Koch was made to finish off those who did not die with his entrenching spade, or be executed himself.

Subscribe or Sign In to read the full article