The American Civil War by John Keegan - review by Richard Carwardine

Richard Carwardine

No Southern Comfort

The American Civil War


Hutchinson 375pp £25

At the crux of American history stands the nation’s Civil War. Four strenuous years of blood-letting forced recalcitrant state sovereignties to recognise the permanence of the Union and the primacy of its federal authority. The emancipation of four million black slaves, though not part of the war’s formal agenda at the outset, became a means, and eventually an end, of the North’s victory on the battlefield; African-Americans’ freedom set in train an evolution of race and labour relations that continues to this day. The world’s first mass democracy demonstrated that popular, elective government, then in its infancy, need not be a casualty of war. Abroad, too, the war helped inspire nationalists, liberals and progressives: many flocked to the Union’s colours, even as conservatives rejoiced at the prospect of the failure of the Yankee experiment in republicanism.

As we approach the one hundred and fiftieth anniversary of that conflict – launched in April 1861 when the Confederates shelled a federal fort in Charleston harbour – we must nerve ourselves for commemorative overload. This October marks the sesquicentennial of John Brown’s abolitionist raid on the federal

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

RLF - March

A Mirror - Westend