Christopher Bray

Singing for Their Supper

We’ll Have Manhattan: The Early Work of Rodgers & Hart


Oxford University Press 360pp £22.99 order from our bookshop

What we might call the Whig theory of Broadway history holds that it was only when Richard Rodgers abandoned the increasingly drunken Lorenz Hart to write blockbusters with Oscar Hammerstein II that the musical became a coherent whole. After Oklahoma! (1943) it was impossible to write mere song-and-dance spectacles. Musicals were now unified fields: numbers weren’t just sprinkled incontinently over some feeble yarn; now they grew organically out of a meaningful narrative. This, argues Dominic Symonds in We’ll Have Manhattan, is nonsense. Right from the jump, he says, Rodgers and Hart sought to render story and song indivisible. 

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • 'Picturesque scenery, hard work in uncomfortable surroundings, eccentric locals, the yearly round: all the ingredie… ,
    • Tarantino's latest film is 'a fairy tale about Hollywood, where fantasy is an industrial product and the boulevards… ,
    • 'I don’t think we’re here on Earth to be Happy. I think we’re here on Earth to help God. I am a messianic writer'.… ,
    • 'Darley’s book is not a mad dash through this most compelling and complex of English counties. Nor is it another ti… ,
    • 'Moser’s book offers such a gripping account of a profoundly damaged human being, trapped in a cycle of repetition,… ,
    • 'Ideas that I’d thought were set down in full continue to smoulder ... this book is only a snapshot of some larger… ,
    • 'Full of invention which, at its most pedestrian, is eminently Victorian, and at its most unrestrained wildly imagi… ,