When is a country born? For the biographer of a mere mortal, a date of birth is a simple matter of fact, or, at worst, an extrapolation. But when the biographer’s subject is an entire land, it is a trickier matter. The origins of some countries are lost in the mists of time. For others, the pall of mythology is so heavy that no amount of tugging will yield an answer. Then there is the question of what to take as the moment of birth: date of independence, first stirrings of political life, earliest settlement by Homo sapiens, perhaps even the separation of the continents?

In the case of Brazil, Lilia Moritz Schwarcz and Heloisa Maria Murgel Starling plump for 1500, the year in which Pedro Alvares Cabral, commander of a Portuguese fleet bound for India, veered off course and struck the eastern flank of South America. It’s a conservative choice for two authors who flaunt their progressive credentials. Schwarcz and Starling do acknowledge the millennia of human settlement preceding colonisation, but only as an ordinary biographer might open with an ancestral table. This book, first published in Brazil in 2015, is very much a history of the land since – to use an old-fashioned term – its discovery.

Subscribe or Sign In to read the full article