Power and the Palace: The Inside Story of the Monarchy and 10 Downing Street by Valentine Low - review by Robert Hazell

Robert Hazell

Strong Constitution

Power and the Palace: The Inside Story of the Monarchy and 10 Downing Street

By

Headline Press 416pp £25
 

Following the success of Courtiers: The Hidden Power Behind the Crown (2022), Valentine Low has adopted the same methods to explore wider relations between the palace and the government. He draws on memoirs, biographies, government and parliamentary papers and, above all, the many interviews he was able to conduct thanks to his unrivalled contacts as a respected former royal correspondent for The Times. The result is a serious and nuanced analysis which is also a rollicking read, spiced with plenty of good stories: many of his 660 footnotes record the source of an anecdote as ‘Author interview’, some attributable, some tantalisingly not.

Low’s account spans 200 years, beginning with William IV and ending with Charles III. The first three chapters cover five reigns, those of Queen Victoria, Edward VII, George V, Edward VIII and George VI; the next eight chapters cover a single one, the seventy years of Elizabeth II. In spite of that, the earlier chapters don’t feel rushed or short-changed. They record in depth the extent to which the earlier monarchs interfered in ministerial appointments and in government (especially foreign) policy. Gradually, that interventionism has given way to a more hands-off conception of constitutional monarchy, where modern monarchs would not dream of interfering in the manner of their predecessors.

Queen Victoria was shameless in her favouritism and partisanship. At the beginning of her reign she was smitten with Lord Melbourne and at the end besotted by Disraeli – she began by supporting the Whigs and ended supporting the Tories, when a politically impartial monarch should have supported neither. She had no time for constitutional conventions and was particularly difficult and obstructive to Gladstone as prime minister. Her intense dislike of him clouded her judgement about the basics of parliamentary democracy, as is revealed in her expression of dismay at Gladstone’s victory in the General Election of 1892: ‘It seems to me a defect in our much famed constitution to have to part with an admirable government like Lord Salisbury’s for no question of any importance or any reason, merely on account of the number of votes.’

It may nevertheless be asked how much effect Queen Victoria actually had on government policy. Apart from keeping Sir Robert Peel out of office in 1839 (the Bedchamber Crisis) and so delaying his second premiership until 1841, it is hard to point to any substantive impact. Victoria’s constant meddling was irritating to her ministers, but hardly changed the course of history. Surprisingly, the monarchs with the strongest claims to having influenced politics are the self-effacing George V and George VI. In the case of George V, he chose Baldwin instead of Curzon in 1923, establishing the precedent that the prime minister could no longer sit in the House of Lords; in 1931 he persuaded Ramsay MacDonald not to resign, but instead to head a national government, burning his boats with the Labour Party. The diffident George VI can claim credit for preventing Churchill (with great difficulty) from being part of the armada that launched the D-Day landings and, after the war, for persuading Attlee to appoint Ernest Bevin as foreign secretary instead of Hugh Dalton. 

The long reign of Elizabeth II might be thought to have provided plenty of opportunities for royal influence, but the examples mentioned by Low seem trivial in comparison. One notable victory at the start of her reign was to insist, against the advice of Churchill and the Cabinet, that her coronation should be televised. More significant was her unwavering support for the Commonwealth, particularly at times of crisis, when her prime ministers (Heath and then Thatcher) saw little point in an organisation which came together to criticise them. 

It was, however, in Queen Elizabeth’s reign that the convention of the monarch having no discretion in the choice of prime minister became established. This was formalised in The Cabinet Manual, which states firmly that the monarch must appoint the person best able to command the confidence of the House of Commons, and that it is the responsibility of the political parties, not the monarch, to identify that person. This guidance proved essential in the hung Parliament of May 2010, when the queen remained at Windsor while the parties negotiated what became the Conservative–­Lib Dem coalition. 

The monarch is still the ultimate constitutional longstop, with power to dismiss a rogue prime minister and to deny an ill-timed request to prorogue or dissolve Parliament. All three elements had the potential to come into play during the turbulent premiership of Boris Johnson. But in his final chapter, Low reminds us that the secret of the monarchy’s continuing success has been the decision to allow its political power to shrink to almost nothing. Alongside this, new justifications for the monarchy’s existence have emerged: that in an increasingly polarised world, the monarchy symbolises what unites rather than what divides us; that it represents continuity and stability, and brings us together at times of national celebration and national crisis (think of the late Queen’s Covid broadcast); it supports charitable and voluntary endeavour through royal visits and patronage.

The amount of autonomy that individual monarchs enjoy has shrunk significantly, too. It would be unthinkable now for a monarch to make an unscheduled visit to a foreign head of state, as Edward VII did when he travelled to Paris in 1903 and helped usher in the Entente Cordiale. But the royals can still indicate where their sympathies lie. When King Charles was advised by Liz Truss not to attend the COP27 conference on climate change, he held a reception at the palace for the attending environmentalists instead. Prince William has a longstanding interest in Israel–Palestine, having visited the West Bank in 2018, and bravely released a statement about Gaza in February 2024. In so doing he was asserting the ability of the heir apparent to be more outspoken than the sovereign – a prerogative which Charles exploited to the full when he was Prince of Wales.

Throughout Low’s chronicle of the internal machinery of government–palace relations, he has been careful to give voice to critics of the monarchy, from Walter Bagehot to Tony Benn. His account provides plenty of ammunition for those who would prefer Britain to become a republic: in the innate conservatism of the court, the flummery, the excessive ceremonial at meetings of the Privy Council – but not in the abuse of power. It is hard not to conclude that, with just two exceptions (Victoria and Edward VIII), we have been fortunate that all of our recent monarchs have been model constitutional heads of state; and they in turn have been fortunate to have Valentine Low as their chronicler.

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.