Blair Worden

The Pen & the Sword

God’s Fury, England’s Fire: A New History of the English Civil Wars


Allen Lane / The Penguin Press 784pp £30 order from our bookshop

There has been nothing in English historical writing over recent decades to match the intensity of interest in the civil wars of the mid-seventeenth century. The foundations were laid a century or so ago, when S R Gardiner, aided by his protégé C H Firth, brought to the period a depth of chronological and documentary investigation that other periods have rarely or never acquired. Gardiner did not write well. His contemporaries, used to reading less searching but more eloquent narratives, were dismayed by his ‘barren and poverty-stricken prose’. Half a century passed before historians with more trenchant pens – R H Tawney, Lawrence Stone, Hugh Trevor-Roper, Christopher Hill, Jack Hexter – built on Gardiner’s foundations to create the analytical excitement of ‘the gentry controversy’ and of parallel attempts to relate the wars to long-term social and economic developments. Those debates commanded a lay as well as a professional audience. Yet in the next generation, with the rise of the doctoral thesis, civil war scholarship became predominantly the preserve of academics, who wrote only for each other. 

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • Something of an 'eccentric billionaire’s hobby': reviews 'The Space Barons: Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and… ,
    • "At the age of fifteen, drunk on stolen Chardonnay or stoned on pot at a swimming party, the thoughts that come imm… ,
    • For the latest Bookends, here's Alan Taylor musing on his stint as an assistant librarian. ,
    • A ‘pretentious ass and impotent arriviste’ who surrounded himself with ‘degenerates, hooligans, childish layabouts,… ,
    • . reviews 'Aristotle’s Way: How Ancient Wisdom Can Change Your Life' by ,
    • "As Beevor shows, it was one of the most daring, dangerous and fiercely fought operations of the whole war. It was… ,
    • "The characters are very rich and very male, with astronomical ambitions. The potted biographies in this book sugge… ,