Brian Young

What It Is To Be Human

A History of Histories: Epics, Chronicles, Romances and Inquiries from Herodotus and Thucydides to the Twentieth Century


Allen Lane / The Penguin Press 553pp £25 order from our bookshop

The modesty of John Burrow’s title, preferring as it rightly does the indefinite to the definite article, is reflected in the attractive and becoming modesty with which he undertakes an unprecedented exploration of over two thousand years of historical writing. His book is a hugely ambitious project, and one which works wonderfully. That it does work so satisfyingly for the general reader is due, in no small part, to its author’s now sadly unusual sense of the historian’s need for intellectual modesty when considering the chronicles of human experience. Although Burrow properly disavows the temptation to write a grand narrative, there is a consistent theme in the book, which is what one might call a peculiarly historical sensibility, concerned with the sheer multiplicity of human experience and the plurality of histories resulting from considered reflection on that experience. If he is occasionally impatient with the ‘scientific’ variant of history that grew up in the new-found intellectual and political confidence of nineteenth-century Europe and America, complete with its grand narratives and self-conscious achievement of historical ‘objectivity’, it is largely because it tends to ride arrogantly over the larger sensibility which Burrow identifies in historians from ancient Greece to such celebrators of the everyday details of the human comedy as the late Richard Cobb.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • Lecture on war and peace in 19th-century Europe by Professor Sir Richard Evans, Thurs 25 Oct, 6.30pm Europe House… ,
    • 'Why, throughout the world, are so many people fascinated by the fiction and reality of espionage? And why of all p… ,
    • . here on books, Muriel Spark and life's tangled dance ,
    • RT : There aren't enough aggressive subtitles these days: ,
    • Churchill's on the cover of the October edition of the magazine. Piers Brendon reviews two new books about the Brit… ,
    • 'Readers have no more power to predict where the next story is going to take them than the prisoners had to determi… ,
    • 'Ho was no Soviet or Chinese puppet. He was a nationalist first and foremost. Had the Americans just realised this.… ,