John Smith – The Slow, Steady Rise of Labour's New Leader by Andy McSmith - review by Matthew Parris

Matthew Parris

Where’s the Beef?

John Smith – The Slow, Steady Rise of Labour's New Leader


Verso 224pp £17.95 order from our bookshop

'I do not know what species of bird is halfway between a hawk and a dove, but I fancy the posture of that bird.' Here. John Smith is talking about nuclear disarmament, but the posture has served him well more than once. Among those of us who hardly know him, Mr Smith's image may be dull, but it is solid and on balance pleasing. Impressions of Labour's new leader show a notable consistency across a wide range of commentors. Words like 'prudence' and 'integrity', 'steadfastness', 'resolution' and 'judgement' spring to mind. 'Honour', especially, springs to mind. So I took up Andy McSmith's new study expecting to have those preconceptions nourished by stories of his youth, his early political career and days as a minister, and news of his behind-the-scenes role through Labour's turbulent dark age in the Seventies and early Eighties.

I was disappointed. The Labour leader emerges from McSmith's researches slightly but perceptibly diminished. The strength I hoped to find never emerges; instead, there is a deeply worrying sense that keeping out

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

East of the Wardrobe

Follow Literary Review on Twitter