Jonathan Mirsky
The Mighty Qin
The First Emperor of China
By Frances Wood
Profile Books 209pp £15.99
The First Emperor: China's Terracotta Army
By Jane Portal (ed)
The British Museum Press 240pp £25
‘Short-lived as it was, Qin bequeathed a heritage that has informed every type of government in China thereafter, be it imperial, republican, Maoist, or post-Maoist’, writes Frances Wood. As the Qin, China's first dynasty, lasted only from 221 to 206 BC, that sentence may strike you as reckless hyperbole. Mao certainly didn't think so. In May 1958, having silenced most of China's intellectuals, the Great Teacher, referring to Qin's founding emperor, Shihuangdi, boasted: ‘He buried 460 scholars alive; we have buried 460,000 scholars … We have surpassed the [First Emperor] a hundredfold.’ Continuing Mao's praise of the First Emperor, in 1974 the Party's leading journal, Red Flag, proclaimed that ‘book burning was a necessary measure during the process of the dictatorship of one exploiting class replacing another’. Mao never buried hundreds of thousands of intellectuals – except metaphorically – and there is little evidence that Qin Shihuangdi did either, nor did he order the burning of many books. But Mao was speaking against the 2,200-year-old tradition of Chinese historians, most of whom blackened the name of the First Emperor, and making clear that the Qin dynasty laid the framework by which China was governed in the succeeding dynasties.
Is that more hyperbole? No. Consider the entire area of Qin at full stretch: from around Beijing, down to near Canton, and from the East Coast out to Sichuan. Except for the extensive Mongol (1279–1368) and Manchu (1644–1911) dynasties, neither of them ethnically Chinese, that still constitutes pretty much China
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
‘At times, Orbital feels almost like a long poem.’
@sam3reynolds on Samantha Harvey’s Orbital, the winner of this year’s @TheBookerPrizes
Sam Reynolds - Islands in the Sky
Sam Reynolds: Islands in the Sky - Orbital by Samantha Harvey
literaryreview.co.uk
Nick Harkaway, John le Carré's son, has gone back to the 1960s with a new novel featuring his father's anti-hero, George Smiley.
But is this the missing link in le Carré’s oeuvre, asks @ddguttenplan, or is there something awry?
D D Guttenplan - Smiley Redux
D D Guttenplan: Smiley Redux - Karla’s Choice by Nick Harkaway
literaryreview.co.uk
In the nine centuries since his death, El Cid has been presented as a prototypical crusader, a paragon of religious toleration and the progenitor of a united Spain.
David Abulafia goes in search of the real El Cid.
David Abulafia - Legends of the Phantom Rider
David Abulafia: Legends of the Phantom Rider - El Cid: The Life and Afterlife of a Medieval Mercenary by Nora Berend
literaryreview.co.uk