Andrew Lycett

A Case of Identity

Arthur & Sherlock: Conan Doyle and the Creation of Holmes


Bloomsbury 245pp £18.99 order from our bookshop

Michael Sims starts his sprightly disquisition on the origins of Sherlock Holmes with the familiar story of Joseph Bell, senior surgeon at Edinburgh’s Royal Infirmary in the late 19th century. One day in around 1880 a visitor tells Bell that he is at the hospital seeking treatment for elephantiasis. Bell responds by showing off his well-honed consultation technique. He correctly surmises that, based on various visual and other clues, the man had, until recently, served as a non-commissioned officer in a Highland regiment and been stationed in Barbados. Why that in particular? Because elephantiasis was endemic in the West Indies. Bell could tell he’d been in the military because, although respectful, he hadn’t taken off his hat on entering the room.

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter

  • Last Tweets

    • 'It is one of those nice linguistic ironies that English should have attempted to make sex respectable by clothing… ,
    • 'He was to my mind the father of the idea that journalism – yes, even journalism – can have a moral dimension to it… ,
    • RT : Feeling old, as exhumes a piece I wrote 37 years ago. But a joy to see Kathy O’S there too. Here’s why:… ,
    • 'Enough of his character remains just out of reach for Barnes to relish the challenge of imagining him.' Patrick M… ,
    • RT : I did a thing about the new Penguin Book Of Oulipo for this month’s Literary Review: @Lit_Review,
    • 'Moore’s work has been so influential that the former ministers who provided him with much of his information now r… ,
    • 'Although he travels through time and space to find the best produce, his choices, delightfully, are not obvious.'… ,