Donald Rayfield
Black Sea Battleground
Crimea: A History
By Neil Kent
Hurst 224pp £20
The Crimean Tatars: From Soviet Genocide to Putin’s Conquest
By Brian Glyn Williams
Hurst 217pp £20
Since the Crimean War of 1853–6 there has been little information for the English-speaking reader on Crimea’s history and peoples. Only the American scholar Alan Fisher has used the necessary Ottoman archives and other Turkic sources, but his writings, published in Istanbul in 1998, are not readily available. Putin’s annexation of Crimea, however, has induced Hurst to produce two brief monographs.
Neil Kent’s Crimea should be subtitled travesty, not history. Careless with facts and even spellings, poorly researched and biased, it was obviously not peer-reviewed before publication. Like Kent’s A Concise History of Sweden of 2008, this book omits crucial events, expands trivialities and abounds in errors. The Crimean War is allotted some thirty pages; the 350-year history of the Crimean Khanate, among Europe’s most influential and well-documented states, is allowed just twenty.
Kent begins with a whirl through Crimean antiquity. The ‘aborigine’ Taurideans (Taurians in Kent’s book), he tells us fancifully, have an ethnonym cognate with English ‘tower’. (What little we know of the Taurideans’ tribal names and skull shapes suggests they were Pontic, like the Circassians.) By 500 BC, Iranian nomads
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Twitter Feed
The son of a notorious con man, John le Carré turned deception into an art form. Does his archive unmask the author or merely prove how well he learned to disappear?
John Phipps explores.
John Phipps - Approach & Seduction
John Phipps: Approach & Seduction - John le Carré: Tradecraft; Tradecraft: Writers on John le Carré by Federico Varese (ed)
literaryreview.co.uk
Few writers have been so eagerly mythologised as Katherine Mansfield. The short, brilliant life, the doomed love affairs, the sickly genius have together blurred the woman behind the work.
Sophie Oliver looks to Mansfield's stories for answers.
Sophie Oliver - Restless Soul
Sophie Oliver: Restless Soul - Katherine Mansfield: A Hidden Life by Gerri Kimber
literaryreview.co.uk
Literary Review is seeking an editorial intern.