Loose Connections: From Narva Maantee to Great Russell Street by Esther Menell - review by Jeremy Lewis

Jeremy Lewis

Queen of the Slush Pile

Loose Connections: From Narva Maantee to Great Russell Street

By

Westhill Books 280pp £13.95
 

When I started work in the late Sixties, literary publishing depended to an extraordinary extent on an army of highly literate women, mostly middle-aged, usually unmarried and always extremely badly paid, who would struggle home every evening and weekend heavily laden with typescripts and proofs to be edited and corrected in their spare time; and on a group of enterprising Jewish émigré publishers who had revitalised the trade immediately after the war. Both groups are integral to Loose Connections, a subtle interlacing of family and professional life.

It takes time to adjust to this book, which darts confusingly between the distant and recent past, family history and publishing life, but persistence pays off. Esther Menell’s parents were Estonian Jews. Her grandfather had pioneered the extraction of oil from shale gas, and other members of the family inherited his entrepreneurial flair. She was born in London in 1934, but spent her early years in Tallinn. Against her mother’s wishes, her father was persuaded to return to London in 1939. Those members of the family who remained behind were murdered by the Nazis. ‘Beside these lives and deaths, the goings-on in a publisher’s office are paltry stuff indeed,’ she writes, ‘but I have only my own life to tell.’

Following boarding school and Oxford she decided to try her luck in publishing. After working for Methuen and Anthony Blond – the publisher she remembers most fondly – she came to rest at André Deutsch, where she remained for some thirty years. Deutsch, who gave his name to the company he founded, was small, energetic, notoriously penny-pinching and equipped with a thick Hungarian accent. His co-directors, Diana Athill and Nicolas Bentley, provided the editorial authority that complemented his entrepreneurial flair. Their list included Norman Mailer, Philip Roth, Brian Moore, Mordecai Richler, Laurie Lee, John Updike and Roy Fuller.

I first met Esther Whitby, as she then was, in 1968, when I went to work at Deutsch. ‘The Queen of the Slush Pile’, as she calls herself, she worked in a gloomy basement that reeked of gas. An old-fashioned ‘hands-on’ editor, she kept a low profile, was paid peanuts and dutifully did her reading at home on the grounds that it was ‘as vital to the life of publishing and as unremitting as housework and housekeeping are to daily life’. But she gradually began to build up her own list of authors. She was sent to Devon to meet Jean Rhys. Athill warned her that Rhys ‘couldn’t type, had got stuck with her novel and drank too much’, but the novel that eventually emerged was The Wide Sargasso Sea. Athill later ‘pulled rank’ as a director and appropriated Molly Keane’s Good Behaviour, which the author’s agent had submitted to Menell. A shared pleasure in books and gossip ‘re-established the friendship, but it was never quite what it had been’.

All self-respecting publishers have a list of masterpieces or bestsellers that they have rejected, and Deutsch was no exception. The firm published Edmund White’s first two books, but not the book which made his name, A Boy’s Own Story. As Menell explains:

when I eventually got the manuscript home – it had fallen off the back of my bicycle in Camden High Street – and sat down to read it, it fell far short of expectations. It was certainly good enough to publish but compared with the earlier books this was dull stuff: I had been White’s most vociferous and only champion (indulged by André because his earlier books had been cheap to buy in) but I couldn’t fight his corner on this one and we let it go.

Deutsch could be mean-minded and vindictive, and though the firm tended to publish leftward-leaning writers, he became ‘incandescent’ with rage when the poorly paid staff tried to join a trade union and threatened to close down the firm. After he sold the business to Tom Rosenthal, civil war broke out between the two men, leading to the eventual demise of the company as we knew it. But for all the penny-pinching, ‘the place felt like Home’, symptomatic, in retrospect at least, of ‘an unattainable Eden’. This clever, unillusioned and disconcertingly honest memoir is a marvellous evocation of publishing as it once was, for good and for bad.

Sign Up to our newsletter

Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.

Follow Literary Review on Twitter