Laura Gallagher
When She Croaked
Emma Donoghue’s eighth novel takes as its starting point the unsolved murder of historical figure Jenny Bonnet, a cross-dressing frog-catcher living in San Francisco in the 1870s. The murder mystery, however, is tangential to the real heart of the book. The protagonist is French émigré ‘Blanche’ Beunon, circus acrobat turned high-class prostitute and, more recently, mother; Jenny Bonnet is only the catalyst for dramatic change in Blanche’s life as she frees herself from a parasitic lover-pimp and fights for her child and independence. Two narrative strands – one opening on Jenny’s death and following Blanche in the aftermath; the other apprising us of preceding events – mount in parallel to the twin denouements that are the solution of the murder and Blanche’s acquisition of self-knowledge.
Unfortunately, some readers may not make it this far. The first quarter of Frog Music is as ‘frail’ – ‘a namby-pamby euphemism for selling it’ – as the women ‘of no character’ who people its pages. The drama of the post-murder strand is laboured:
The bullets winging over her head as
Sign Up to our newsletter
Receive free articles, highlights from the archive, news, details of prizes, and much more.@Lit_Review
Follow Literary Review on Twitter
Where now for active asset-management in the wake of the Woodford Equity Income collapse? My review of @davidricketts's When the Fund Stops and @OwenWalker0's Built On A Lie in @Lit_Review https://literaryreview.co.uk/stock-horror-2
'What if the 1492 "discovery" of America had been a fiasco, the major effect of which was to alert the Incas to the existence of a land to the east that might be ripe for conquest?'
@lieutenantkije on Laurent Binet's new novel, 'Civilisations'.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/1492-and-all-that
'Humans may be the supremely musical animal, but, with or without us, this is a musical planet.'
@MathewJLyons on how music on earth began.
https://literaryreview.co.uk/symphony-of-a-thousand-millennia